Exploring the Shadows of the Past: A Review of 'Before We Were Yours' by Lisa Wingate

Bookey Best Book Summary App

Chapter 1:Summary of Before We Were Yours Full Book

"Before We Were Yours" by Lisa Wingate is a poignant and powerful novel inspired by real-life events involving the Tennessee Children’s Home Society in the first half of the 20th century. The story is told through two interconnected timelines, blending past and present to create a compelling narrative.

In the historical timeline, set in 1939, the novel follows the Foss children, who live a happy life on a shantyboat on the Mississippi River with their parents. Their world is upended when they are kidnapped by the corrupt Georgia Tann, the director of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. Tann is notorious for forcibly taking poor children and selling them to wealthy families across the country. The Foss children find themselves trapped in a cruel, abusive orphanage system. The eldest sister, Rill, fights hard to protect her siblings and keep the hope of reuniting with their biological family alive, despite the harsh realities and terrible conditions they face.

The contemporary timeline follows Avery Stafford, a successful federal prosecutor and the daughter of a prominent South Carolina family. While helping her father during a health crisis, Avery stumbles upon a mysterious family secret after encountering May Crandall, an elderly woman in a nursing home who seems to have some connection to Avery’s beloved grandmother. Driven by curiosity and the need to understand her family’s past, Avery delves into her grandmother's history, uncovering her connection to the horrors perpetrated by Georgia Tann.

As Avery discovers more about the Tennessee Children’s Home Society and the trauma it inflicted, she unravels the threads connecting her family to the Foss children, exposing deep secrets that were meant to stay hidden. Meanwhile, through the story of the Foss children, the novel highlights the strength of family bonds and the resilience required to endure and overcome tremendous adversity.

"Before We Were Myours" is a blend of historical fiction and family saga, exploring themes of family, identity, and redemption. It showcases the catastrophic impact of corruption and exploitation, but also the indomitable spirit of those who fight for justice and truth.

Chapter 2:The Theme of Before We Were Yours Full Book

Key Plot Points

"Before We Were Yours," a historical fiction novel by Lisa Wingate, is inspired by real events surrounding the Tennessee Children's Home Society scandal, which operated under the guise of a charitable orphanage from the 1920s to the 1950s but was actually involved in the kidnapping and illegal adoption of children. The novel presents dual narratives between past and present:

1. 1939 Narrative (Past) - The Foss Children:

- The story follows the five Foss children led by the eldest, twelve-year-old Rill Foss. She and her siblings are abducted from their river shantyboat, The Arcadia, by police officers aiding Georgia Tann, the head of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society.

- The children are taken to a boarding facility where they suffer abuse and neglect. They witness and endure harsh treatments and manipulations by Tann and her associates, aimed at coercing them into adoptable states that erase their pasts.

- Throughout their ordeal, Rill struggles to keep her siblings together and maintain hope of reuniting with their biological parents, Queenie and Briny Foss.

2. Present-Day Narrative:

- The book alternates to the present-day story of Avery Stafford, a successful prosecutor from a prominent South Carolina family. She returns home to help her father, a senator who faces health problems.

- During a nursing-home visit at a campaign photo op, Avery encounters May Crandall, a mysterious elderly woman who mistakenly thinks Avery is someone from her past. This meeting piques Avery's curiosity about her family’s history.

- Avery uncurls a sequence of secrets and connections tracing back to the Tennessee Children’s Home Society, uncovering the fact that her grandmother, Judy Stafford, was possibly one of the children caught up in the scandal.

Character Development

- Rill Foss (May Crandall in present-day): Rill starts as an innocent, carefree child, knowledgeable about river life but naively unaware of the outside world’s harshness. The events she goes through force her to mature quickly, focusing on survival and protection of her siblings. In later years, as May, she becomes a resilient, courageous woman who finally speaks about her traumatic childhood.

- Avery Stafford: Initially portrayed as a polished, controlled woman molded by her family’s political ambitions, Avery’s encounter with May and her subsequent investigation into her family’s secrets show her transformation into a more empathetic, independent individual who values truth and justice over political convenience.

Thematic Ideas

- Identity and Family Heritage: The novel explores the scandalous stripping away of children’s identities and the lifelong impact of such traumatic experiences on their sense of self and the concept of family.

- Corruption and Greed: The role of Georgia Tann and her accomplices demonstrates the influence and greed that pervaded an institution charged with the welfare of the helpless, highlighting moral corruption.

- Resilience and Survival: Through Rill's character, the story illuminates themes of resilience and the enduring will to survive and protect loved ones, even in the direst circumstances.

- Revealing Hidden Histories: Avery's journey underscores the importance of unearthing and confronting family and societal secrets, thus bringing long-overdue recognition and justice to victims.

In conclusions, the book is a moving, often harrowing exploration of loss and love, shedding light on a dark chapter in American history while also painting a tender picture of family and resilience.

Chapter 3:Meet the Writer of Before We Were Yours Full Book

Lisa Wingate is known for her compelling narrative style, detailed character development, and emotionally laden prose, especially in her novel "Before We Were Yours." This book draws upon historical events centered around the notorious Tennessee Children's Home Society scandal, where children were kidnapped and sold to wealthy families. Wingate uses various writing techniques and styles to deepen the emotional impact of the story and enhance readers’ engagement with the themes.

Narrative Structure

"Before We Were Yours" employs a dual timeline narrative, alternating between past and present. This structure allows Wingate to weave historical details seamlessly with contemporary life, providing a stark contrast that highlights the lasting impact of family secrets and lies. The shifts between timelines are designed to keep readers engaged and to slowly uncover the connection between the storylines, thereby building suspense and emotional resonance.

Characterization

Wingate's choice of characters and their development throughout the novel is central to its emotional depth. The characters, primarily the Foss children, are deeply explored. By depicting their fears, hopes, strengths, and vulnerabilities, Wingate prompts readers to invest emotionally in their journey and survival. The children’s perspectives are particularly poignant and effectively convey the emotional and physical harshness they endure. In contrast, the modern-day storyline, centered around Avery Stafford, slowly peels back layers of personal and familial identity, exploring themes of legacy and self-discovery.

Language Style

Wingate uses a lyrz]ically descriptive language that vividly paints the setting and the emotional landscape of the characters. Her use of language not only serves to anchor the reader in the time and place but also highlights the emotional states of the characters. For example, descriptions of the family's river life in the past storyline carry a nostalgic, almost idyllic quality contrasted sharply with the harsh, clinical descriptions of the orphanage. This disparity in tone enhances the emotional impact of the children's suffering.

Themes and Motifs

Wingate's portrayal of themes such as family, identity, and survival is woven throughout both narrative threads. She uses the characters’ experiences and internal monologues to explore these deeply personal and universally relatable themes. Motifs like water, which represents both life and danger, and windows, symbolizing both visibility and barriers, recur throughout the book. These symbols reinforce the emotional and thematic undertones of the story.

Emotional Resonance

Perhaps one of the most striking aspects of Wingate's writing in "Before We Were Yours" is her ability to evoke emotions. Through the hardships of the Foss children, Wingate explores the resilience of the human spirit in the face of despair and injustice. Emotional cues are built not just through big revelations but also through small, detailed moments such as a child's fleeting memory of home or a casual remark that uncovers a deeper truth in the modern-day storyline.

In sum, Lisa Wingate's "Before We Were Yours" effectively utilizes a combination of narrative structure, deep characterization, evocative language, recurring themes, and motifs, and emotional depth to explore profound themes and historical events. Her engaging style not only brings history to life but also prompts readers to reflect on their own family histories and the shadows they may conceal.

Chapter 4:Deeper Understanding of Before We Were Yours Full Book

"Before We Were Yours" is a historical novel by Lisa Wingate, published in 2017. The book delves into a significant and heartbreaking chapter of American history, centered around the Tennessee Children’s Home Society scandal, a real-life adoption scam run by Georgia Tann. Through her agency, Tann kidnapped and sold poor children to wealthy families across the country from the 1920s through 1950. The novel is structured as a dual narrative that alternates between the 1930s, following the lives of the Foss children who are forcibly removed from their parents and placed in the Tennessee Children’s Home Society orphanage, and the present day, depicting a federal prosecutor’s investigation into her family's mysterious past.

Influence on Literature

"Before We Were Yours" has garnered significant acclaim and popularity, shedding light on a lesser-known historical incident through the emotionally gripping and personal stories of its characters. By using the powerful medium of historical fiction, Wingate has contributed to the genre similarly to other authors like Kathryn Stockett or Kristin Hannah, who explore profound and sometimes difficult aspects of American history. The novel encourages a reflective engagement with the past, making it accessible and compelling through personal and family stories.

Impact on Culture and Society

1. Awareness of Historical Events: The novel has increased public awareness about the Tennessee Children’s Home Society scandal. For many readers, it was the first they had heard of Georgia Tann and her adoption scheme, highlighting how significant historical events can fade into obscurity until revived through literature.
2. Ethics in Adoption: By exploring the corrupt practices of the past, the book invites readers to consider the ethical dimensions of adoption and child welfare not only historically but also in contemporary times. It provokes discussions about the ways in which children are protected and how systems meant to aid families can sometimes fail them.
3. Personal Reflection and Connection: The story resonates with readers who have experienced adoption, either personally or within their communities, sparking conversations about identity, family heritage, and the long-lasting effects of separation from biological families.
4. Book Clubs and Discussions: As a popular choice for book clubs, the novel serves as a catalyst for discussions about historical accountability and restitution. Such discussions often extend beyond the book, encouraging individuals to explore more about the era and other historical injustices.

Changes in Thinking

"Before We Were Yours" has likely influenced readers to think more critically about the history of child welfare and adoption. It also acts as a reminder of the potential for systemic abuse and the importance of vigilance and accountability in institutions designed to protect the vulnerable. Additionally, it has brought attention to the emotional journeys of those who have been adopted and their efforts to understand their origins.

Impact on a Particular Field

In terms of academic and professional fields, the novel may serve as an interesting case study in social work and child welfare education programs, where it can be used to discuss historical practices and their evolution. It can also spark dialogues about ethical standards in sectors dealing with child care and protection.

In summary, "Before We Were Yours" is a poignant example of how historical fiction can play a critical role in illuminating the past, shaping cultural conversations, and influencing societal attitudes towards significant issues such as family, identity, and ethics in caregiving practices.

Book https://www.bookey.app/book/before-we-were-yours

Quotes https://www.bookey.app/quote-book/before-we-were-yours

YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4p7sB0esKE

Amazom https://www.amazon.com/-/zh/dp/0593599004

Goodreads https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32148570-before-we-were-yours?from_search=true&from_srp=true&qid=urLg1AHYGa&rank=1